Climate skepticism report's LLM peer review accused of selective citation
Understand this story
A climate expert panel appointed by the Trump administration used large language models such as Copilot and Grok to review drafts while writing a report criticizing climate science, and the models flagged problems in it. According to Hacker News AI, Copilot found that their evidence was often selectively picked to support a positive view of CO2, and that they frequently used wording such as exaggerated and alarmist, and also noted that their cited sources were "outdated or narrow." The panel consists of five climate experts appointed by the Trump administration, and the report has not yet been finalized; the above judgments come from the models' review comments, not from an independent assessment of the report's conclusions.
AI overview based on source reports · Updated 4 hr ago
Coverage timeline
Follow the coverage to explore different perspectives.
- Hacker News AIClimate skeptics used AI to review their work. It told them they were biased
Documents released after a judge ruled the Energy Department's Climate Working Group violated the Federal Advisory Committee Act show the five experts used LLMs such as Microsoft Copilot and Grok as research assistants, editors and reviewers. Copilot's review of their report warned that evidence was "often cherry-picked to support a CO2-positive view" and that words like "alarmist" and "science fiction" compromised objectivity, prompting edits to remove "skeptic talk." Members said AI did not determine content, though they grew frustrated that the models favored consensus sources and Koonin had Copilot draft a limerick criticizing the Fifth National Climate Assessment.
Activity for this story
- Current comparable activity
- 9
- Peak comparable activity
- 10Nov 7 21:00
- Change in the past 24 hours
- –
Trends compare the same fully observed participants, which may cover fewer participants than current activity. Move the pointer or tap the chart to inspect hourly activity; use the left and right arrow keys with a keyboard.