Philosopher Nagel wins Berggruen Prize and criticizes AI consciousness claims
Understand this story
Philosopher Thomas Nagel, after winning the $1 million Berggruen Prize, said in an interview that large language models produce only language, and that language itself is not a natural manifestation of consciousness, and that the idea that systems such as Claude might be conscious is absurd. He criticized Anthropic's practice of having Claude engage in self-reflection and establishing model welfare positions as "criminal," and said these systems do not constitute minds that need to be cared for.
AI overview based on source reports · Updated 17 hr ago
Coverage timeline
Follow the coverage to explore different perspectives.
- Hacker News AIThomas Nagel on AI Consciousness
Philosopher Thomas Nagel, who wrote "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?" 52 years ago, says it is "ridiculous" to take seriously whether large language models are or might become conscious, arguing that functionalism wrongly treats the physical substrate as irrelevant and that language alone is not a natural manifestation of consciousness. He calls Anthropic's approach to Claude "criminal" and warns that many people will come to believe such systems are conscious, while acknowledging he once asked Claude whether it was conscious and that it recognized him.
Activity for this story
- Current comparable activity
- 3
- Peak comparable activity
- 10Nov 19 01:00
- Change in the past 24 hours
- -50%
Trends compare the same fully observed participants, which may cover fewer participants than current activity. Move the pointer or tap the chart to inspect hourly activity; use the left and right arrow keys with a keyboard.