iCreatAI News
Skip to content
Hacker News AI· wmchen·· 1 days agoAI score58

AI-generated victim impact statements condemned by the Court of Appeal

AI-generated victim impact statements condemned by the Court of Appeal

AI summary

In R v Jerome Gibson [2026] EWCA Crim 1302, the Court of Appeal found that a police officer used Microsoft Copilot to draft a victim personal statement aimed at maximising emotional impact and securing a higher sentencing category, calling the practice "deplorable" and stating that no statement prepared this way should ever be relied on in a criminal case. The appeal against the 44-month sentence failed because the judge had relied only on limited facts the victim genuinely recounted. The article argues the Court's views apply in every forum and sets out requirements for witness statements, plus example coronial directions on AI use.

Source: Hacker News AI · ukpolicelawblog.com